图 1.从加热食用油到可测量健康指标的完整链条。越往下证据强度越低:链条最上端的化学过程
十分确凿;最下端的人体心血管结局则只有观察性数据支持。来源:Leong 2021,《Frontiers in Nutrition》
(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
3. 哪种脂肪生成哪种醛
图 2.每种醛都有自己的"母体"脂肪。油酸——橄榄油和高油酸菜籽油中的主要
脂肪——根本无法生成 4-HNE,它分解成壬醛和 2-癸烯醛。因此对于高温烹调,有用的问题是"这种油的亚油酸
含量有多高",而不是"油酸含量有多高"。来源:Grootveld 2022 前体对照表;Ma 2020(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
图 3.八种油,温度相同、时间相同。排序基本跟随亚油酸含量:椰子油与高油酸葵花籽油
最低,葡萄籽油最高。值得注意的是,两种橄榄油虽然亚油酸含量与高油酸葵花籽油相近,4-HNE 却更高——
这说明抗氧化物质含量也在起作用。来源:Liu 2017(椰子、棕榈、红花、葡萄籽);Yuan 2018(橄榄、葵花)
(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
关于上表的两点诚实说明。第一,椰子油、棕榈油、红花籽油和葡萄籽油的数值来自一篇
硕士学位论文,而非同行评议期刊论文——这是唯一以该方式测量这四种油的来源,我们如实标注。
第二,大豆油的 36.9 微克/克是在 180 °C 而非 185 °C 下测得,因此它只能指示
其在排序中的位置,并非完全同条件的数值。
4.2 各油生成 4-HNE 的速度
换一种方式测同一件事:每加热一小时生成多少 4-HNE。这组数据覆盖了 5 小时实验未包含的油种。
图 4.185 °C 下 4-HNE 的生成速率。玉米油、大豆油和猪油——亚油酸含量都
很高——生成速度约为牛脂的 30 倍、菜籽油的 6 倍。菜籽油速率较低,反映其亚油酸含量较低、且亚麻酸含量也
明显更低。来源:Liu 2014(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
图 5.亚油酸含量——最有用的单一参考指标,因为它在不同油脂间差异极大:椰子油约
1 %,红花籽油接近 80 %。柱形表示不同文献报道的范围。来源:Abrante-Pascual 2024 综述表 1;
Wroniak 2021;Zhou 2024;Warner & Gupta 2005;Yuan 2018(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
4.3 同一规律的其他测量方式
4-HNE 并非唯一的醛类,不同研究测量不同的指标。但每一种都把富含亚油酸的油排在最前。
图 6.大豆油在 180 °C 下,用核磁共振追踪 90 分钟内各类醛的生成。其中
"4-羟基/4-氢过氧基-2-烯醛"这一类正是包含 4-HNE 与 4-HHE 的类别;该研究中这是一个类别测量,
而非单个化合物。注意不饱和醛类的上升速度远快于羟基烯醛——它们构成了总量的主要部分,
尽管羟基烯醛反应性更强。来源:Wann 2021(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)图 7.180 °C 加热 90 分钟后生成的毒性 α,β-不饱和醛类总量。葵花籽油与玉米油
最高,橄榄油较低。注意菜籽油在此高于特级初榨橄榄油——排序会随指标改变,这正是为什么单一数字无法说明
全部问题。来源:Moumtaz 2019(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
图 8.茴香胺值——衡量包括醛类在内的二级氧化产物总量——在 180 °C 深炸
18 小时后的结果,横轴同时标出各油的亚油酸与亚麻酸含量。两项都最高的常规菜籽油超出定量上限;亚油酸不到
一半的高油酸菜籽油低得多;棕榈液油最低。常规菜籽油显示的 200 是下限值,而非精确读数。来源:Wroniak 2021
(Figure recreated from data published under CC BY 4.0; adapted, not reproduced.)
Leong X-F. Lipid Oxidation Products on Inflammation-Mediated Hypertension and Atherosclerosis: A Mini Review.
Front Nutr 2021;8:717740. doi:10.3389/fnut.2021.717740(CC BY 4.0)
Yuan J, Shoeman DW, Csallany AS. Formation of 4-Hydroxy-2-Trans-Nonenal, a Toxic Aldehyde, in Thermally Treated
Olive and Sunflower Oils. J Am Oil Chem Soc 2018;95(7):813–823. doi:10.1002/aocs.12098
Liu X.《The effect of temperature and heating time on the formation of alpha,beta unsaturated hydroxyaldehydes
in various vegetable oils and fats》. 明尼苏达大学硕士学位论文,2014. hdl.handle.net/11299/166843
——生成速率数据来源
Liu A.《Temperature Dependence of 4-Hydroxy-2-Trans-Nonenal (HNE), a Toxic Aldehyde, in Coconut, Palm, Safflower
and Grape Seed Oils》. 明尼苏达大学硕士学位论文,2017. hdl.handle.net/11299/193414
——上述四种油 185 °C/5 小时数据来源
Bastos LCS, de Almeida Costa EA, Pereira PAP. Development, validation and application of an UFLC-DAD-ESI-MS
method for determination of carbonyl compounds in soybean oil during continuous heating. Food Chem
2017;218:518–524. doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2016.09.036
Wann AI, Percival BC, Woodason K, Gibson M, Vincent S, Grootveld M. Comparative 1H NMR-Based
Chemometric Evaluations of the Time-Dependent Generation of Aldehydic Lipid Oxidation Products in Culinary Oils
Exposed to Laboratory-Simulated Shallow Frying Episodes. Foods 2021;10(10):2481. doi:10.3390/foods10102481
(CC BY 4.0)——大豆油各类醛数据
Moumtaz S, Percival BC, Parmar D, Grootveld KL, Jansson P, Grootveld M. Toxic aldehyde generation in and food
uptake from culinary oils during frying practices. Sci Rep 2019;9:4125. doi:10.1038/s41598-019-39767-1
(CC BY 4.0)
Chiang K-M, Xiu L, Peng C-Y, Lung S-CC, Chen Y-C, Pan W-H. Particulate matters, aldehydes, and polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons produced from deep-frying emissions. npj Sci Food 2022;6:28.
doi:10.1038/s41538-022-00143-5(CC BY 4.0)
Wroniak M, Raczyk M, Kruszewski B, Symoniuk E, Dach D. Effect of Deep Frying of Potatoes and Tofu on
Thermo-Oxidative Changes of Cold Pressed Rapeseed Oil, Cold Pressed High Oleic Rapeseed Oil and Palm Olein.
Antioxidants 2021;10(10):1637. doi:10.3390/antiox10101637(CC BY 4.0)
Zhou Z, Gao P, Zhou Y, Wang X, Yin J, Zhong W, Reaney MJT. Comparative Analysis of Frying Performance:
Assessing Stability, Nutritional Value, and Safety of High-Oleic Rapeseed Oils. Foods 2024;13(17):2788.
doi:10.3390/foods13172788(CC BY 4.0)
Grootveld M. Evidence-Based Challenges to the Continued Recommendation and Use of Peroxidatively-Susceptible
Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid-Rich Culinary Oils for High-Temperature Frying Practises. Front Nutr
2022;8:711640. doi:10.3389/fnut.2021.711640(CC BY 4.0)
Abrante-Pascual S, Nieva-Echevarría B, Goicoechea-Oses E. Vegetable Oils and Their Use for Frying: A Review of
Their Compositional Differences and Degradation. Foods 2024;13(24):4186. doi:10.3390/foods13244186
(CC BY 4.0)
Petersen KD, Jahreis G, Busch-Stockfisch M, Fritsche J. Chemical and sensory assessment of deep-frying oil
alternatives for the processing of French fries. Eur J Lipid Sci Technol 2013;115(8):935–945.
doi:10.1002/ejlt.201200375——此处仅通过二次引用报告;全文需付费
Warner K, Gupta M. Potato Chip Quality and Frying Oil Stability of High Oleic Acid Soybean Oil.
J Food Sci 2005;70(6). doi:10.1111/j.1365-2621.2005.tb11462.x
Ma L, 等. The effect of heating on the formation of 4-hydroxy-2-hexenal and 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal in unsaturated
vegetable oils. Food Chem 2020;321:126603. doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2020.126603
——仅作引用;版权所有,未复制任何图表
Schaur RJ, Siems W, Bresgen N, Eckl PM. 4-Hydroxy-nonenal — a bioactive lipid peroxidation product.
Biomolecules 2015;5(4):2247–2337. doi:10.3390/biom5042247
Bjelakovic G, 等. Mortality in Randomized Trials of Antioxidant Supplements for Primary and Secondary
Prevention. JAMA 2007;297(8):842–857;勘误 2008;299(7):765–766。再检视见 Biesalski HK 等,
Nutrients 2010;2(9):929–949. doi:10.3390/nu2090929
Klein EA, 等. Vitamin E and the Risk of Prostate Cancer: Updated Results of SELECT. JAMA
2011;306(14):1549–1556
12. 许可与转载
本页所有图表均由我们依据开放获取论文中发表的数据重新绘制,并非直接复制原图。其中多项来源
采用 CC BY 4.0 许可,允许在署名前提下使用与改编:Leong 2021、Moumtaz 2019、Chiang 2022、
Wroniak 2021、Zhou 2024、Grootveld 2022、Abrante-Pascual 2024 以及 Wann 2021。署名见各图注及上方参考文献。